It’s one of those questions that pops up all the time in ecommerce circles. You’re setting up your email flows, and you get to that money-maker: the abandoned cart sequence. Then the thought hits you. Are abandoned cart emails transactional or marketing? It feels like it could be either, right? The answer, especially as we head through 2025, isn’t as simple as a yes or no. It’s a messy mix of both, and getting it wrong can land you in some pretty hot water with email laws. So let’s just get into it and try to make sense of this whole thing.
The Big Split: Transactional vs. Marketing Emails Explained
First things first, we need to know what we’re talking about. These two types of emails are totally different beasts, with different rules.
A transactional email is something your customer sort of expects to get. It’s triggered by an action they took. Think order confirmations, shipping notices, or password reset links. The whole point of it is that it’s an email sent to complete an action a user already took, like confirming an order they just made. You don’t need special permission to send these normally.
Marketing emails on the other hand are a different story. These are your newsletters, your promo blasts, your “20% off” sales. Their main job is to sell stuff. For these, you absolutely need someone’s clear permission, what they call an opt-in. They have to have said “Yes, please send me marketing stuff.”
So, Where Do Abandoned Cart Emails Actually Fit In?
This is where things get super blurry. An abandoned cart email is triggered by a user’s action (adding to cart), but its purpose is to get them to do something else (buy it). So which bucket does it fall into? It’s a debate that people have.
The Case for Them Being Transactional-ish
The argument here, it kind of makes sense at first. The person put an item in their cart. They started a transaction. Your email is just a helpful reminder, a bit of customer service to help them finish what they started. Maybe their internet died or their kid started screaming. You’re just checking in. “Hey, did you forget this?”
This view treats the email as part of the checkout process itself. It’s an extension of the shopping experience they initiated. So under this logic, it could be considered to be transactional.
The Stronger Argument: They’re Marketing, Mostly
Now for the other side of the coin. Let’s be real. Why are you sending that email? It’s not just to be nice. You want to make a sale. You are actively trying to persuade them to come back and spend money. That sounds a lot like marketing, doesn’t it?
Most data privacy laws, like GDPR in Europe and others, they look at the main purpose of the email to decide things. If the primary purpose is to encourage a commercial transaction that hasn’t happened yet, it’s pretty much a marketing message. The goal is persuasion, not just information. This is the view that is generally considered safer.
The Legal Mumbo Jumbo (Simplified for 2025)
The legal side of this is a headache, and it’s always changing. But the general direction is more privacy for users, not less. Which means more rules for us.
GDPR (for the EU) is the big one. It’s very strict about consent. The safest way to operate under GDPR is to assume abandoned cart emails are marketing. That means you need clear, explicit consent from the user before you can send them one. A pre-checked box won’t cut it.
Then you have things like CAN-SPAM in the US. It’s a bit more relaxed but still has rules. The email can’t be misleading and it must identify itself as an ad. And it must, absolutely must, have a clear way for the person to unsubscribe.
The key takeaway from all this legal stuff is that a court or a regulator is more likely than not going to see your “helpful reminder” as a sales pitch. It is better to just assume they are marketing emails from the get-go.
How to Do Abandoned Cart Emails the Right Way (and Stay Out of Trouble)
Okay so what do you actually do? You don’t want to stop sending these emails because they work really well. But you also don’t want a massive fine. It’s about being smart.
Getting Consent is Your Best Bet
The easiest way to cover your bases is to get consent.
Add a clear checkbox at checkout. Right before they enter their payment info, have an unchecked box that says something like, “Email me with occasional offers and reminders.”
Separate it from Terms & Conditions. Don’t bury your marketing consent inside the T&C checkbox. That’s a big no-no, especially under GDPR. It has to be its own separate, clear action.
Once you have that consent, you’re in the clear. You can send them your abandoned cart sequence without worrying.
The first email in your sequence can be pretty neutral. More of a customer service touch. Something like “Did you have trouble checking out?” or “Your cart is waiting for you.” This feels less like a hard sell. It’s just a nudge.
If you have explicit consent, your second or third emails can be more sales-focused. This is where you can introduce a discount code or create a sense of urgency. But you can only really do this safely if they’ve opted in to marketing.
And for goodness sake, make the unsubscribe link big and obvious in every single email. Hiding it is a terrible practice and will get you into trouble. People should be able to leave if they want to.
FAQs About Abandoned Cart Emails
1. So, bottom line: are abandoned cart emails transactional or marketing?
Mostly, they should be treated as marketing. While they are triggered by a user’s action, their primary goal is to persuade a sale, which puts them squarely in the marketing camp according to most privacy laws.
2. Do I really need consent for abandoned cart emails under GDPR?
Yes, to be safe, you absolutely do. The risk of not having explicit, opt-in consent is too high. It’s the only way to be sure you are following the rules.
3. Can I send just one abandoned cart email to someone who didn’t opt-in?
This is a legal gray area and very risky. Some argue a single, non-promotional reminder might fall under “legitimate interest,” but this is a weak argument that is getting harder to defend. The safe answer is no.
4. What’s the difference in content between a transactional vs. marketing abandoned cart email?
A more transactional-feeling one would be a simple reminder of the items left behind, maybe asking if there was a technical issue. A marketing one would include persuasive language, reviews, or a discount code to entice the purchase.
5. How many abandoned cart emails are too many?
There’s no magic number, but a sequence of 2-3 emails sent over a few days is a common practice. More than that and you risk annoying the customer and being marked as spam.
Key Takeaways
It’s much safer to treat all your abandoned cart emails as marketing messages. The law is leaning that way.
Getting clear, un-pre-checked consent from users before sending them these emails is the best way to stay compliant.
Your first email can be a gentle, customer-service-style reminder.
Only use aggressive sales tactics like discounts if you have explicit consent for marketing.
Always, always have a clear and easy-to-find unsubscribe link in every email you send. No exceptions.
Leave a Reply